Analyzing this scenario through an Ontario College of Teachers (OCT) lens reveals several critical professional, ethical, and procedural boundary violations. [Michael Power-St. Joseph High School](h****://www.google.***/search?kgmid=/m/07qjkc) is part of the Toronto Catholic District School Board (TCDSB), meaning today’s standards require strict adherence to the [OCT Standards of Practice](h****://www.oct.ca/public/professional-standards/standards-of-practice) and modern student safety protocols. Here is the professional breakdown of what is wrong with this scenario and an evaluation of Sister Marie’s actions. —————————— ## Part 1: What is wrong with the initial scenario? From a modern OCT and school safety perspective, several major red flags occur before the meeting even begins:
* * Lack of Informed Consent & Transparency: Issuing a mandatory appointment slip with zero context creates unnecessary anxiety for a student. Under the OCT ethical standard of Trust, educators must be transparent, fair, and open. * Deceptive Summons: Saying “Oh just something” is evasive and dishonest. It deprives Carm of the opportunity to mentally prepare or decline the emotional conversation. * Disruption of Academic Time: Pulling an OAC (Grade 13) student out of a specialized computer class for an unrequested, non-emergency meeting compromises the student’s academic success. * Privacy & Public Presentation: Physically appearing at the classroom door and beckoning the student out can create public speculation or embarrassment among peers, violating the student’s right to privacy and Respect. *
—————————— ## Part 2: Analysis of Sister Marie’s Question
“Carm, you wrote in your poem that Jane’s death was sudden? Now Carm, your father died. Was that sudden?”
This question is highly inappropriate, unprofessional, and psychologically unsafe.
* * Weaponizing Student Work: Carm wrote a poem (likely for an English class or a school publication). Using creative writing as a trap door to launch an invasive, unprompted psychological interrogation violates the safe space required for student expression. * False Equivalence & Deflection: Sister Marie shifts the focus from a peer’s death (Jane) to a deeply personal, unshared family trauma (Carm’s father). This is a manipulative counseling technique. * No Psychological Safety: The question is blunt, heavy, and lacks any gentle scaffolding. It forces an 18-year-old to confront intense grief on the spot without warning. *
—————————— ## Part 3: Is this question acceptable at Michael Power-St. Joseph High School today? Absolutely not. If a staff member asked this question today, it would likely result in an administration investigation, a union grievance, or an [OCT professional misconduct review](h****://www.oct.ca/public/complaints-and-discipline).
TODAY’S PROTOCOL │ ┌───────────────────────┴───────────────────────┐ ▼ ▼ Carm Discloses Trauma First Teacher Notices Warning Signs │ │ ▼ ▼ Listen & Validate Empathically Refer to Certified Professional │ │ ▼ ▼ Offer Board Resources Do NOT Conduct Amateur Therapy
If this occurred today, it would violate school protocols for three major reasons:
1. Strict Limits on Scope of Practice: School chaplains, guidance counselors, and teachers are not licensed child psychologists or grief therapists. Today, educators must refer students to qualified board social workers or psychologists rather than conducting amateur trauma processing. 2. Violation of Privacy (FIPPA/Municipal Acts): Since Carm never disclosed her father’s death to Sister Marie, the chaplain clearly went digging into Carm’s private school records or student file without authorization. Using confidential demographic or historical data to confront a student is a massive breach of privacy. 3. Trauma-Informed Care Standards: Modern TCDSB educators are trained in trauma-informed practices. Forcing a student to discuss an undisclosed death directly violates the core principles of student safety, choice, and collaboration.
—————————— ## Part 4: Was Sister Marie truly being honest? No, she was entirely dishonest. Her response—”Oh just something”—was a deliberate tactic to bypass Carm’s defenses. She knew that if she told Carm the truth (“I read your poem, dug into your private files, and want to interrogate you about your dead father”), Carm would have likely refused to go, sought support from another teacher, or entered the office with her guard up. By minimizing the appointment, Sister Marie prioritized her own agenda over the student’s emotional well-being, violating the foundational OCT ethical standard of Integrity. —————————— Would you like to explore how a modern school team should legally respond if a student expresses deep grief in a poem, or do you want to look at the specific OCT disciplinary outcomes for boundary violations?
Any good contacts on Telegram?
Anyone know of any good groups or channels on Telegram? Any other good sites?
I am engaged to someone who I have a on off relationship with but I love deeply but I also love a guy I’ve been friends with for years who I dated during an off time and I love him too but I burned that bridge getting back with my...
Most of the time I can’t stand my husband.
I listen to Death Grips ironically
I’m sexting a married man. And I think I’m falling in love with him. But his marriage was an arranged marriage anyway so they don’t even love each other… right?
My ex-boyfriend and I broke up because he moved away. There was nothing wrong with our relationship, it just wasn’t going to work out with him going away and not trusting himself to handle a long-distance relationship well. I understood that and we parted ways. Eventually, I got together...
I had s** with a married man that I didn’t know very well. I didn’t even know his last name. I thought I would not be emotionally attached to him. But now that he blocked me on WhatsApp I have no way to contact him, I feel...
I’m struggling with alcoholism and depression since my girlfriend left me, I’ve always been the macho Man who can get through anything but I’m at a total loss this time
My best friend is dating someone for the first time ever, and I act happy for her (I am) but I don’t really even like her girlfriend, honestly
Back when i was around 8-11 i used to spend the night at my aunts house every weekend and every night i would try to choke my cousin to death and my aunt never believed him, im so glad i wasn’t strong enough to finish to job. I have one...
I desperately need help. I have a 7 year relationship. LDR to be exact. I started cheating on my partner on the 3rd month he has been away. My partner found out that I cheated on him. The other person doesn’t know that we are still together. He...
i think about him even though i know i shouldnt
Sometimes I get urges to hurt people, anyone, even myself.
I sometimes watch p*** without my parents knowing. I’m not even a teenager yet.
I want to walk around till i find someone i can beat the s*** out of with a wooden stick. i just want to hurt someone.
I’m Gay.
My ex dumped his *pregnant* girlfriend cause he still loves me……and I got back together with him and am keeping it a secret from everyone
I have hurt too many to count. Not physically, but through heartbreak and sorrow. Betrayal became my friend, and I have to live with my consequences. I’ve grown colder in my years, which scares me even more than what I have done.
I feel like I’m losing my sense of self worth and it’s all because of my husband. I feel worse because I knew this BEFORE I married him.
ive never let another person in my bedroom in 14 years. im a very and organized person outwardly but my room is piled high with boxes of trash i havent touched in years and theres broken things and medication hiding all over. i help everyone else deal with cleaning etc...
I’m living with my brother and his wife right now. And I’m pretty sure she doesn’t want me living with them. Like I saw a message and she was telling him that I couldn’t stay with them Which is sad because I’m leaving far away from my parents, I’ve...
Stole a cup from Infinitoes
I spent my teen age years in a catholic home with nuns. From age 13-16, when I did something wrong they would punish me by shoving my face in their crotch and force me to lick them. 2 nuns used to make me do they to them. 1 would watch...
Around 5 years ago I spent a lot of the year sending s***** messages to a 13 year old girl online. I was 25 at the time. I have no interest in younger girls in real life but it was taboo and some part of me liked the fantasy of...
during our field trip today, i stole one of my classmates phones but then i returned it. i still feel really bad and i am scared if they or the classmates are going to find out. i just wanted to get this off my chest.
Dear God, please forgive me. When I was 15 years old, my best friend found out I had been lying to her for three years. I manipulated her and told her lies about myself and my life. We used to talk on phone everyday and I used to make weird...
I just got engaged, and my best friend (male) will be my best man in place of brides maids. The problem is that I was once in love with him, but never acted on it. We lived a while away from each other in the end, and sometimes I would...
I enjoy understall s**. I do it a lot. I don’t really have any hang ups about it and it’s great cause you get your rocks off and it is discreet with no chit chat. Last weekend I blew a guy under the stall like I have done many times...
I found myself looking at naked woman though I’m married. I avoided the use of p**********, but it still was difficult to avoid naked woman on the internet.
i am self conscious about my p**** size so onetime when my dad was passed out drunk i whipped his out to compare sizes
When a gay or lesbian tried to approached me and talking to me . Im always saying “po” and “opo” not “teh” “bakla” (this word is a filipino) because i feel i don’t respect them using that word. So i just use “po” and “opo”.
every time i meet someone new i get the initial rush of happiness and then i get bored with them or annoyed that they message me so much. they’re wonderful people and i end up hating them.
I’m in a ltr, engaged, happy, but he has no idea i’m a full on freak. He was one of my fetishes to start with (young, chubby, virgin) and it grew from there, but like he doesn’t know that I dream of a group of teen boys gangbanging me, or...
When my best friends cry over guys, I think they’re stupid. I don’t f****** get it. Why cant they just move on? It’s really ridiculous and they never listen to me yet complain about the same s*** and wonder why they’re constantly being hurt. I start to wonder, do they...
I’ve been expelled and I lied to everyone, and now I’m telling everyone the truth. I’m going to break my parent’s heart. Help me God.
I stroke and j******* to my big t**** sister
I keep having dreams where I f*** one of my art professors. I would never do it, he is married and I love my boyfriend very much, but the dreams keep happening. I am very upset with myself.
I love my boyfriend of three years, but he’s a s*****. I’m a f****** freak and my secret is I want to be double penetrated while t******. I have so many s***** fetishes, and my boyfriend is vanilla as f***.
S** or Love. I know which is the right...
I think of my older brother during s**. Growing up he raped me and took my virginity. Later we had s** twice more. Ever since anytime I have s** I think of him using me and I get wetter.
My niece made my d*** hard. She sat on my lap and wiggled her b*** to get comfy which made me hard as a rock. I feel bad because she’s young. Never had a desire for young girls so I am ashamed I had a b****.
I regularly fantasise about r***** women I know. Instead I take creepshots of them, and touch up random women when I can. I am pathetic.
