On Thursday, Columbia University published a study with a grim finding: Since May, as most of the aid from the $2 trillion CARES Act that Congress passed in the spring has dried up, eight million people in the United States have fallen into poverty. “The CARES Act was unusually successful,” one of the study authors told The Times, “but now it’s gone, and a lot more people are poor.”
Congress, after months of gridlock, seems poised to continue doing nothing about it. On Wednesday, Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said that talks with Speaker Nancy Pelosi over more aid remained tense and that he did not expect a package to be approved before the Nov. 3 election.
With millions more hanging on a knife’s edge of financial ruin, some 90 percent of voters want Congress to pass another relief package. Why isn’t it happening?
The deal on the table
The House of Representatives has twice passed follow-up relief packages — a $3.4 trillion one, the Heroes Act, in May and a scaled-back $2.2 trillion version this month — but both went nowhere in the Senate, where Republican members disputed the necessity and cost of additional aid.
After abruptly halting negotiations on Oct. 6, President Trump, recognizing the political peril of obstructing desperately needed relief while running for re-election, has tried to split the difference between the House and the Senate: The White House’s latest offer, which Mnuchin presented to Pelosi last Friday, is a $1.8 trillion proposal including the following provisions:
A second round of $1,200 stimulus checks with an additional $1,000 per child (up from $500 per child)
$400 enhancement of weekly unemployment insurance benefits (down from the $600 enhancement that expired at the end of July)
$300 billion for state and local governments
$300 billion in small-business loans
$175 billion for health care providers and coronavirus testing, vaccine development and distribution
$100 billion for student loan, food and housing assistance
While substantially smaller than either of the bills the House passed, it is the largest bid the White House has yet made.
The holdup in the House
Pelosi promptly rejected the White House’s offer, which she said “amounted to one step forward, two steps back.” In a contentious interview with Wolf Blitzer on Tuesday in which he told her not to let the perfect be the enemy of the good, she responded that the administration’s offer was “not even close to the good.”
Chief among her objections is the proposal’s lack of language for a federal plan for coronavirus testing, tracing and treatment, the absence of which is widely regarded as a critical failure in America’s pandemic response.
Even so, some House Democrats and commentators believe the speaker should accept the $1.8 trillion deal for the sake of those who cannot afford to wait: As of September, employers had hired back less than half of the 22 million workers they laid off in March and April, and the number of Americans filing jobless claims every week, already at a staggering level, has surged in October. Without additional aid, economists warn, the country could enter a downward spiral.
