6 years
x
178 Views

Clinical Trials of Coronavirus Drugs Are Taking Longer Than Expected

Antibody trials sponsored by Regeneron and Eli Lilly are off to a slow start because of a dearth of tests, overwhelmed hospitals and reluctant patients.
A monoclonal antibody clinical trial site in Mesa, Ariz., is kept bare to ensure a faster disinfection process. Testing delays, difficulty finding trial sites and challenges to enrolling patients have hindered the research.
A monoclonal antibody clinical trial site in Mesa, Ariz., is kept bare to ensure a faster disinfection process. Testing delays, difficulty finding trial sites and challenges to enrolling patients have hindered the research.Credit…Adriana Zehbrauskas for The New York Times

By Katie Thomas Aug. 14, 2020 Updated 3:21 p.m. ET

As the coronavirus pandemic continues to wreak havoc in the United States and treatments are needed more than ever, clinical trials for some of the most promising experimental drugs are taking longer than expected.

Researchers at a dozen clinical trial sites said that testing delays, staffing shortages, space constraints and reluctant patients were complicating their efforts to test monoclonal antibodies, man-made drugs that mimic the molecular soldiers made by the human immune system.

As a result, once-ambitious deadlines are slipping. The drug maker Regeneron, which previously said it could have emergency doses of its antibody cocktail ready by the end of summer, has shifted to talking about how “initial data” could be available by the end of September.

And Eli Lilly’s chief scientific officer said in June that its antibody treatment might be ready in September, but in an interview this week, he said he now hopes for something before the end of the year.

“Of course, I wish we could go faster — there’s no question about that,” said the Eli Lilly executive, Dr. Daniel Skovronsky. “I guess in my hopes and dreams, we enroll the patients in a week or two, but it’s taking longer than that.”

A spokeswoman for Regeneron, Hala Mirza, said that all clinical trials involved an early learning period, and that the company was “seeing positive momentum in recent days” as it has sent testing machines to some research sites and has broadened criteria to allow more patients to participate.

While much of the world’s focus has been on the race to create a coronavirus vaccine, new drugs could also help curb the pandemic by making the disease less deadly. Because drugs are typically tested in sick patients in smaller clinical trials, they can also be developed more quickly than vaccines.

Eli Lilly and Regeneron are pursuing two of the most closely watched treatments: lab-engineered antibodies that could either fight off the virus in patients who are already sick or prevent infections in those who have been exposed. Although the Trump administration has heavily favored investment in vaccines, Regeneron has won deals from the federal government worth more than $500 million to ramp up manufacturing of its antibody treatment.

Both companies rushed to develop their products in record time and began large studies this summer at dozens of hospitals and clinics around the country. They are testing various groups of patients, such as those who are positive but not yet sick enough to be hospitalized, and those who have been exposed to the virus from someone already infected. All of the trials compare the experimental drugs to a placebo, or sham treatment.

The fast-moving disease has presented opportunities and challenges for the researchers testing antibodies. As the number of infections mounted in states like Florida, Texas and Arizona, there was no shortage of patients who would be eligible for trials. But at the same time, the outbreaks overwhelmed the very hospitals that would be overseeing the studies.

In remote meetings with doctors at trial sites around the country, Dr. Skovronsky said some had to step out to care for patients who required emergency intervention.

“That doesn’t happen when you’re setting up diabetes trials or cancer trials,” he said. “We’ve had investigators say: ‘Look, I’d love to do research, but I don’t have time to set up a new trial. I’ve got an I.C.U. full of patients.’”

One major hurdle has been testing. In both of the outpatient trials run by Eli Lilly and Regeneron, doctors must compete with a ticking clock. According to the rules of the Regeneron trial, a patient must be treated with the antibodies within seven days of the onset of symptoms. Both the Regeneron and Eli Lilly trials require giving the drug within three days of taking a positive test.

But with turnaround times in some areas lagging for five days or more, keeping within those time frames has proved difficult.

Dr. Anita Kohli, the director of research at Arizona Clinical Trials, a Regeneron trial site in Mesa, Ariz., said she got a rush of people wanting to volunteer for the outpatient study earlier this summer, when the outbreak was peaking in her state. “Our phones were ringing, probably off the hook the first two weeks,” she said.

But as labs were inundated with samples, straining supply chains and delaying results, Dr. Kohli said enrolling patients became difficult. “If people are getting tested at these facilities, but they don’t have the results, then how do we enroll them in trials?” she said.

Dr. Kohli said Regeneron sent her a rapid-testing machine to speed up the results, and Eli Lilly did the same for its trial, which she is also running. A spokeswoman for Regeneron said the company had sent out “a few dozen” testing machines to clinical trial sites, and was planning to send more in the coming days.

Eli Lilly said it was working with state health departments and other local authorities to help speed up testing in certain areas, in addition to supplying some sites with testing machines.

Other researchers said finding the right spot to give the experimental treatment to outpatients was complicated. Patients typically get tested at a drive-through site, and then return home, rarely visiting a hospital or clinic unless their condition gets worse. Bringing them into a medical center for treatment further strains the system, and risks infecting patients and health care workers who don’t have Covid-19.

Some sites have resisted bringing a highly infectious person onto their medical campuses, potentially sharing a lobby or elevator with people who do not have the virus. Once there, they must spend a few hours receiving an infusion of the treatment as well as getting blood tests and completing paperwork required for the study.

At some hospitals, officials have been able to use existing facilities. In Tyler, Texas, the UT Health North Campus medical center is an old tuberculosis hospital, with rooms that use negative air pressure to prevent viruses from spreading.

But in other locations, like Holy Cross Hospital in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., finding the right spot has been a struggle. Dr. Joshua Purow, who is overseeing the Eli Lilly outpatient trial at the hospital, rushed to get his site ready once he saw that infections were rising in the area.

But Holy Cross turned down his first choice, a corner of the emergency department, out of fears that the space would be needed for more severe Covid-19 patients. The idea of installing an outdoor tent was deemed too complicated, and refurbishing a room in a nearby office building would take precious weeks.

Weeks passed before Dr. Purow finally secured a place to run the trial. It was in the emergency department, the first place he had requested.

“We finally have it all set up to go,” Dr. Purow said. “But now, our numbers are declining a little bit. We’re not seeing as much as we thought we would.”

So far, he said, he has enrolled just one participant, out of a hoped-for 25. Over all, the Eli Lilly outpatient trial is aiming for including 400 patients. The similar Regeneron study has a goal of enrolling about 1,500 patients.

Not every trial site is seeing such hurdles. Dr. Jason Morris, who is overseeing the Eli Lilly study at his physician practice, Imperial Health, in Lake Charles, La., has already exceeded his goals and has enrolled about 45 patients. Dr. Morris said he or another doctor calls each person who tests positive for the virus at the group’s urgent care clinic and tells them about the study.

He said he explains that the study is examining whether Eli Lilly’s antibody can stop the virus from invading cells and replicating. “When I break it down pretty simply like that, people are like, ‘Oh, let’s do that,’” he said.

But some patients are reluctant to participate. Many people associate clinical trials with treatments that are given in life-or-death situations, and don’t want to risk taking an experimental drug for an illness they may overcome on their own. Others have the opposite rationale: They don’t want to go through the hassle of a trial only to receive a placebo.

Dr. Imad Shawa, who is leading the Eli Lilly trial at Franciscan Health Indianapolis, said people must decide whether to enroll in the trial before they get very sick.

When test results come back, “the majority of the time, patients are even slightly feeling better, or they’re not getting any sicker,” he said. “So the perception is that all this is another mild thing that they can deal with.”

Doctors who are running studies are prohibited from making a hard sell — patients must be informed of the risks and benefits of participating, and the very nature of a clinical trial means that no one knows if the treatment will work.

“We can’t sort of paint it as a positive or a negative,” said Dr. G. Marshall Lyon III, who is leading the Regeneron clinical trials at Emory University in Atlanta. “We don’t know if it’s going to be directly beneficial to you; we don’t know if it’s going to be harmful to you.”

Dr. Lyon, who said enrollment in the trial was going more slowly than he expected, said most people ended up “taking a wait-and-see attitude.”
The New York Times

New Confession

Living with aunt….she sat me down for an evening talk. Overall good, she was proud of me and how i had been obeying her. She was also happy that i had accepted maintenance spankings multiple times a week from the neighbors, even if my aunt could have done it herself. Those were only afternoon spankings sometimes when i got home from classes. Sometimes one or both of the neighbor women were there waiting when i got home, sometimes as soon as i got home she would send me next door for my afternoon spanking. She was also happy that even with how uncomfortable it made me, that i so readily accepted having to keep an ice pack between my thighs when the soankings came from them, and my aunt had started incorportating ice packs into my spankings from her sometimes. She said she was very proud of me for seeming to mostly even if not always have the mindset that being spanked was something i happily and eagerly looked forward to every day no matter who did it. She even laughed when i said my favorites were morning shower spankings with her, and she teased me that that was because i was getting to see a n ak ed woman every morning. She said that she felt that deliberately allowing me to sexualize her was a small price to pay for my improved behavior, and she absolutely wanted to make sure that no matter how often the neighbors may spank me, she still made it very clear that i should never ever allow mysellf to sexualize when they spanked me. I tried to assure her that i was not doing that, but she responded that they would all be keeping a close eye out for that risk. She relayed multiple ongoing concerns that she kept close in mind, that it was far roo early to think i was “cured” of my obsessive and compulsive habits of playing with myself far beyond anything that was healthy or normal or natural or good for me. She assured me that she was very pleased with how being spanked had mostly replaced how much i wanted to touch and play with myself, but that eventually my behavior needed to be reliable and not critically dependent upon being spanked. She pointed out that yes this was by far the longest i had ever gone without playing with myself, but that could not be relied upon because based in my truthful answers to her questions, i had been doing it so long so heavily that i simply did not have the history to realize that the longer i went without doing it the harder it would be to resist doing it. That eventually i would need to be self reliant on avoiiding abusing my body. She said the hardest part for me was going to be how to have sanity in pleasure without obsession. She also told me that one thing that still worried her the most was my past behavior of teaching myself how to use my own mouth for pleasure and that that was still a matter of self obsession and degrading myself for immature reasons. She told me that her biggest worry for the short term was that i needed to realize how much harder it would get every single day the longer i went. She had been told by my mother of how my mother had caught me folded up tightly and using my own mouth several times, and my aunt said she was worried that it was a behavior i might return to some day, especially since i had not had an o r g asm for weeks by the time of this conversation. She admitted that she was torn on the concept of rewarding my behavior by very cautiously allowing myself an o r gasm, and thinking that it definitely needed to be determined what my breaking point would be in terms of how long i could behave while going without. That that process would be a very uncertain thing, and she was unsure whether i understood that the intense physical sensations of being spanked were probably serving as a substitute for the intensity of an o r g a sm. That she was still mulling things over in her mind, trying to get me to understand at 18 that it was not sane or healthy in any way to think in terms of being regularly spanked daily as a long term solution, and that at some point i would have to learn what a normal sane s e xu al relationship with a woman looked like without relying on spankimg or playing with myself. She told me that she knew it would probably be a little embarassing but that she and the neighbor women….who were sisters, our landlords, and my aunt,s long term lovers….had been having these exact conversations about long term sanity vs short term control of my behavior. I tried to make her feel better about that by reminding her that they already knew of all my bad behavior and verbally chastised me when they spanked me, but she said she owed me the full truth. She also told me something that truly upset me….that both of the neighbors had posed what my aunt felt waa a very valid concern ..
Whether using my own mouth was simply about self pleasure or whether it was an obvious indication that i was actually gay. I was upset and asked her how that could be possible when i was obviously and visibly very aroused by her every morning in the shower, and she said that that was not a true indicator, that she knew me well enough now that morning shower arosual over her being in the shower with me could be a form of immature behavior, that it was quite possibly mental or emotional because i had a safe approving outlet for what i knew was bad behavior and something that even i knew was my own dirty little secret. She told me she knew it was upsetting to hear and told me that that was probably the one thing that would be hardest to figure out in all of this, and that she did not have a lot of very important answers for things that it was too early to know. It bothered me a great deal and i tried to explain to her that using my own mouth was just something that was far more pleasurable than my hands and that i sometimes hit periods of time in the past where it was impossible to have my o r g asm by hands alone. Even she was upset when she explained to me that there must be more to it than that because i had done it commonly and that it was such an extreme concept that most men would never even think of, much less try, and even much less do repeatedly. The concept of being thought of or seen as gay was very upsetting to me and my aunt understood that because she herself said that the world views lesbians far more favorably than gay men and that even i would realize how much more stigmatized gay men were over their entire lives. But she said that while it can take a long time over a person’s life to truly kniw their s***** preferences internally much less in the world’s eyes, that if i was gay it was something in my case that she felt was more important, because at that point even her willingness amd comfort itln being okay with deliberately allowing me to sexualize her, not just my new outlet of being spanked, could have impacts for years or even across my entire life by creating attachments fixations or habits or assumptions that could prevent me from having healthy sane relationships that could meanbi was never happy or comfortable with myself or others. We were both very upset by now in the conversation esp me i was pacing and arguing against what she was concerned about. She finally scolded me and ordered me to sit down and talk to her but i was still anxious and fidgeting and she caught me completely off guard, and asked me what i would usually do when my mother was upset with me. I could not admit the truth so she said it herself. That i ma st urb ated when i was upset or angry or anxious, even when i was upset because she was on my back about or had just caught me playing with myself. She could tell it was true because i was sobbing. She held me and tried to console me, tried to help me see that that itself was a huge example of my reactions and that that mental and emotional response with a physical reaction was exactly what she was talking about, that my mother had effectively trained me to respond or feel this way with the very behavior that disgusted her. She tried but could not get me to calm down. She was begging me to let her help me but i did not know how, and as i sobbed she did somethiing very wise. She called the neighbors and asked them to xome over, told them everything we had talked about while i sat there both upset and numb, and she went into the kitchen for an ice pack and grabbed them a kitchen spoon and spatula. I was too upset to even question or protest as i was physically pulled to stand and placed over the end of the sofa arm with my pants around my ankles and the neighbor women gave me the most prolonged and harsh but not brutal spanking i had ever gotten. It sort of broke me but also got me out of that awful head space. As i remained bent over hurting from burning cheeks and thighs but also shivering with the ice pack still between my thighs all three women talked and then the neighbors left. My aunt took me to bed and cuddled me but we did not speak any more. The next morning in the shower when my aunt suggested i play with myself for a whole i just turned to face the wall and asked for my spanking. She waa gentle but had to land a lot of the slaps on the insides of my thighs because my cheeks and backs of my thighs were marked and very tender.

To be continued….

Related Confessions