13 years
x
365 Views

I have to control my anger towards my best friend that is about to give birth to her second “opps” baby. I have to remind myself that I should be happy for her and that it isn’t fair to ruin such a beautiful time with my pain. Each month passes, doctors appointments come and go, medicine is taken, diet is watched, extra exercise and water are added, and I take my multi vitamin. Fear that my husband will leave me floods my head. I sink down into this abyss where I realize that my body doesn’t perform the one function that it was biologically programed to do millions of years ago. It becomes sickening how many babies there are everywhere you go, how every shopping trip takes me past a shop with tiny socks and caps in neat rows. Waiting for a baby… but not my baby. How can you love someone so much who you have never met and may never get to meet? I want to give up but I don’t want to give up. It could take years if ever and each month the rollercoaster begins again.

New Confession

Related Confessions

*F*** Sister Marie Howorth for her psychological abuse

*F*** the Dead Deputy Director of the Metropolitan Separate School Board (1937-2014) who told Sister Marie Howorth to psychologically abuse me

*F*** his niece through marriage

From ChaTGPT:

My impression of Sister Marie Howorth is that her approach was deeply intrusive, insensitive, and potentially manipulative, particularly given the circumstances and the fact that you were an 18-year-old student.

There are several things about this encounter that stand out to me.

1. The comment about wearing a mask
“You know you wear a mask.”

That is a remarkably loaded statement to make to a young person, particularly without explaining what you mean.

What was she suggesting? That you were hiding your feelings? That you were presenting a false version of yourself? That she believed she could see something about you that you couldn’t see yourself?

The problem is that she offered an interpretation of your personality without explaining or substantiating it. It could easily leave you feeling exposed, scrutinized, or confused.

2. Her questioning about Jane
I find this part particularly troubling.

You had written a poem about someone whose story had moved you. That experience had inspired you to join peer ministry. There is nothing inherently unusual or inappropriate about being emotionally moved by the death of someone you didn’t personally know.

In fact, it suggests empathy.

But Sister Marie Howorth seemed to approach your poem as though there was something suspicious or psychologically significant about your interest in Jane.

“How did you know Jane?”

“You mean you wrote a poem about a student who died of cancer that you didn’t even know? Why would you do that?”

Those questions could have been asked out of genuine curiosity. However, the repeated questioning, especially in the context of her earlier comment about your mask, suggests that she had already formed some kind of interpretation about you and was trying to get you to disclose something.

3. Bringing your father’s death into the conversation
This is where I find her approach especially concerning.

“Now Carm, you wrote in your poem about Jane that Jane’s death was sudden. Now Carm. Your father died. Was that sudden?”

You had never told her about your father’s death.

I can understand why that question would have been startling.

She took something deeply personal — your father’s death — and introduced it into a conversation about a poem you had written about someone else’s death.

There is a significant difference between inviting a student to discuss grief and unexpectedly confronting that student with a personal loss.

Even if Sister Marie Howorth had a legitimate reason to wonder whether your father’s death influenced your response to Jane’s story, she needed to approach that possibility with considerable sensitivity.

For example, she could have said:

“Sometimes another person’s experience of loss resonates with something we’ve experienced ourselves. I wonder whether that might be true for you.”

That would have left you room to decide whether you wanted to share anything.

Instead, her question was direct and presumptive.

4. Your distress and her continued questioning
This is perhaps the most important part of your account.

You became distressed. You apologized for having written the poem.

Rather than recognizing that the conversation was becoming overwhelming and backing off, Sister Marie continued probing:

“I want to know what made you notice Jane. There must have something that made you notice her.”

I would have expected a chaplain to recognize your distress and prioritize your emotional safety.

You were entitled not to answer.

You were entitled to keep your father’s death private.

You were entitled to write a poem about Jane without having to explain or defend your emotional response.

And you were entitled to participate in peer ministry without having your personal history investigated.

5. What I think may have happened
I want to distinguish between what we can establish from your account and what we cannot know.

I cannot know Sister Marie Howorth’s intentions. Perhaps she believed she had identified a connection between your father’s death and your emotional response to Jane. Perhaps she thought she was helping you explore something unresolved.

But even if her intentions were benevolent, her methods were questionable.

There is something particularly uncomfortable about the combination of:

Summoning you unexpectedly from class.

Making an unexplained observation about your personality.

Questioning the legitimacy of your emotional response to Jane.

Introducing your father’s death without your having disclosed it.

Continuing to press you after you became distressed.

That combination creates an imbalance of power. She was an adult, a religious authority figure, and someone occupying a position of pastoral trust. You were an 18-year-old student in her office, without any advance knowledge of why you had been summoned.

My overall impression is that Sister Marie was intrusive and exercised poor pastoral judgment. I would not automatically conclude that she intended to hurt you, but the impact of her behaviour, as you describe it, was potentially deeply unsettling.

One thing I particularly want to say to you
I find your final response significant:

She will not know how my father died. She will not know what made me notice Jane.

You established a boundary.

You did not owe Sister Marie Howorth your father’s story. You did not owe her an explanation for your poem. And you did not owe her access to your grief simply because she was a chaplain.

I also want to challenge something implicit in your distress: You had done nothing wrong by writing that poem.

Your compassion for Jane did not require justification.

I have one question that I think is important to understanding this encounter: When Sister Marie Howorth asked whether your father’s death was sudden, did you get the impression that she already knew how he died, or was it the fact that she knew he had died at all that shocked you